STATE LAW / UTAH

Utah body shop laws: what insurers and shops must do

The Utah rows from all 8 of our state law guides on one page: what each rule means in plain English, and the law's own words with a link to the official source.

Can the insurer make your customer use their shop?

What it means in Utah

Rule R590-190 bars an insurer from requiring a claimant to travel an unreasonable distance to inspect a replacement car, get a repair estimate, or have the car repaired at a specific repair shop. An insurer that prepares an estimate must give the claimant a copy and may give the names of one or more conveniently located shops. If the insurer elects to repair the car and designates a specific shop, it must have the car restored to its condition before the loss at no added cost to the claimant beyond what the policy states, within a reasonable period. Requiring a claimant to use only the insurer's claim service to perfect a claim is an unfair practice. An independent or public adjuster can't take payment from, or have a financial interest in, a repair firm that gets business from a claim it adjusts, or take a fee or anything else of value for referring an insured to a repair firm. No statute or rule in our Utah collection states a right to choose a repair shop or in terms bars an insurer from recommending one.

Whether R590-190-11(4) bars requiring a specific shop at all, or only where the travel is unreasonable, and whether the claim service rule in R590-190-12(5) reaches a drive-in claim center or a shop program, are not settled by the text and are questions for a lawyer. In Rule R590-190 a claimant is a first party claimant, a third party claimant, or both. Utah Code 31A-26-312 binds independent and public adjusters, not an insurer's own salaried adjusters. Rule R590-190 is enforced by the Utah Insurance Department and says nothing about a private right to sue, and Utah Code 31A-26-303(5) says that section creates no private cause of action.

The law's own words

“(4) An insurer is prohibited from requiring a claimant to travel an unreasonable distance to inspect a replacement automobile, to obtain a repair estimate, or to have an automobile repaired at a specific repair shop.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)

“(b) If an insurer prepares an estimate, it shall give a copy of the estimate to the claimant and may provide the claimant the names of one or more conveniently located repair shops.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)

“(8) If an insurer elects to repair an automobile and designates a specific repair shop for the repairs, the insurer shall cause the damaged automobile to be restored to its condition before the loss at no additional cost to the claimant other than as stated in the policy and within a reasonable period.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)

From a list that begins: “The commissioner finds the following acts to be misleading, deceptive, unfairly discriminatory, overreaching, or an unreasonable restraint on competition in settling a claim:”

“(5) requiring a claimant to use only the insurer's claim service to perfect a claim;”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-12 (effective 6/7/2024)

From a list that begins: “(1) An independent adjuster or public adjuster may not:”

“(b) engage in any other activities that may reasonably be construed as presenting a conflict of interest, including soliciting or accepting remuneration from, or having a financial interest in, or deriving any direct or indirect financial benefit from, a salvage firm, repair firm, construction firm, or other firm that obtains business in connection with a claim that the independent adjuster or public adjuster has a contract or agreement to adjust;”

Utah Code § 31A-26-312 (effective 5/9/2017)

From a list that begins: “(1) An independent adjuster or public adjuster may not:”

“(e) accept a fee, commission, or other valuable consideration of any nature, regardless of form or amount, in exchange for the referral by an independent adjuster or public adjuster of an insured to a third-party person, including an attorney, appraiser, umpire, construction company, contractor, repair firm, or salvage company.”

Utah Code § 31A-26-312 (effective 5/9/2017)

Compare anti-steering laws in all 32 states

Who pays storage on a total loss, and what can a shop charge?

What it means in Utah

Before an insurer stops paying for storage, it must give the claimant reasonable written notice (the rule also calls for claim documentation of the denial) and a reasonable time to remove the car from storage; the rule sets no number of days and no rate. Refusing to pay an insured a reasonably incurred expense that resulted from a delay the rule prohibits is also an unfair practice. If you sell a car under your repairman's lien, the certified-mail sale notice must state your lien for labor and services performed and for interest and storage fees charged, if any. A public garage, a place that charges to keep and store vehicles, must keep a record of each vehicle stored there for compensation longer than 12 hours (Utah Code 41-1a-1105), and must report to local law enforcement on the 11th day a vehicle stored 10 days whose owner it doesn't know. The daily storage maximums in R909-19-15 apply to tow truck motor carriers on non-consent tows, and storage fees under that rule may be charged only at a state impound yard. No statute or rule in our Utah collection caps what a body shop charges for storage on a repair the customer authorized.

Utah Code 38-2-3, the repairman's lien, does not name storage; whether storage is secured by that lien, whether a body shop that charges for storage is a public garage, what a reasonable storage charge is, and whether storage is an expense an insurer must pay under the delay rule in R590-190-9(18) are questions for a lawyer. The repairman's lien is subject and subordinate to the rights and interests of any secured party in the car unless that secured party requested the work. In Rule R590-190 a claimant is a first party claimant, a third party claimant, or both. The rule is enforced by the Utah Insurance Department and says nothing about a private right to sue. Towing, impound and storage fees under Utah Code 72-9-603 and 41-6a-1406 are a separate possessory lien held by tow carriers and impound yards, not the repairman's lien.

The law's own words

Insurer

“(12)(a) An insurer shall provide reasonable written notice to a claimant before termination of payment for automobile storage charges and claim documentation of the denial.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)
Insurer

“(b) An insurer shall provide a reasonable time for the claimant to remove the vehicle from storage before terminating a payment.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)
Shop

From a list that begins: “(b) The notice shall be sent by certified mail at least 30 days before the proposed or scheduled date of any sale and shall contain:”

“(iv) notice that the lienor claims a lien on the property for labor and services performed and interest and storage fees charged, if any, and the cash sum which, if paid to the lienor, would be sufficient to redeem the property from the lien claimed by the lienor;”

Utah Code § 38-2-4 (effective 5/7/2025)
Shop

“If any vehicle, vessel, or outboard motor has been stored in a public garage, state impound lot, or other storage facility for 10 days and the owner is unknown to the proprietor, on the 11th day of storage the proprietor shall report the presence of the vehicle, vessel, or outboard motor to the law enforcement agency in the city or county where the garage, lot, or facility is located.”

Utah Code § 41-1a-1106 (Renumbered and Amended by Chapter 1, 1992 General Session)
Tow and storage lot

From a list that begins: “(1) Daily storage fees for non-consent police generated tow service may not exceed:”

“(a) Outside storage: light duty $40, medium duty $60, heavy duty $60.”

Utah Admin. Code R909-19-15 (effective 10/22/2024)
Tow and storage lot

“(d) Storage fees may only be charged if the place of storage is a state impound yard that meets the requirements of rules made by the commission under Subsection 41-1a-1101(5).”

Utah Admin. Code R909-19-15 (effective 10/22/2024)

Compare total loss storage fees in all 32 states

Can a body shop keep the car until the bill is paid, and can it sell it?

What it means in Utah

If you repair a car at the request of the owner or another person entitled to possession, you have a repairman's lien for the reasonable value of the labor performed and materials furnished and may keep the car until paid, but the lien and your right to keep the car are subject and subordinate to the rights and interests of any secured party, such as a lender on the car, unless that secured party asked for the work. To sell, send notice by certified mail at least 30 days before the sale to the owner, the customer on the work order and everyone claiming an interest in or lien on the car in the Motor Vehicle Division's records (or another state's), and publish it once in a newspaper in the county at least 20 days before the sale if the owner is unknown or a person notified doesn't acknowledge it. No sale may come earlier than 45 days after the repair work is completed, and every aspect of a private sale must be commercially reasonable. The owner can get the car back without going to court by filing a cash or surety bond with a court clerk; you then have 60 days after receiving notice of the bond to sue to foreclose the lien, or the court clerk releases the bond. The owner may redeem before the sale, and you keep your right to sue for your charges or any balance left after the sale.

Utah calls this the repairman's lien; the lien a shop owner may know as a mechanics' lien is the real property lien in Title 38, Chapter 1a, which our collection does not include. Utah Code 70A-9a-333 gives a possessory lien priority over a security interest unless the lien is created by a statute that expressly provides otherwise; how it and 38-2-3 apply to a given lender is a question for a lawyer. Utah Code 38-2-3.1 also gives a special lien, dependent on possession, to a person who works on personal property at the owner's request; whether a vehicle repairer stands on that section, on 38-2-3, or on both is a question for a lawyer. Whether an insurer's authorization counts as the owner's request, whether storage is secured by the lien, what becomes of the lien when the car is released, and what is done with sale money beyond the lien amount are also questions for a lawyer. For the buyer's title, Utah Admin. Code R873-22M-2(5) lists what an applicant submits to title a vehicle foreclosed by advertisement; whether a given sale fits is for the Motor Vehicle Division.

The law's own words

Keep the car

“Every person who shall make, alter or repair, or bestow labor upon, any article of personal property at the request of the owner or other person entitled to possession thereof shall have a lien upon such article for the reasonable value of the labor performed and materials furnished and used in making such article or in altering or repairing the same, and may retain possession thereof until the amount so due is paid;”

Utah Code § 38-2-3 (Amended by Chapter 272, 1977 General Session)
Lender priority

“provided such lien and right to possession shall be subject and subordinate to the rights and interests of any secured parties in such personal property unless such secured party has requested such person to make, alter or repair or bestow labor upon such property.”

Utah Code § 38-2-3 (Amended by Chapter 272, 1977 General Session)
Sell or title it

“The notice shall be sent by certified mail at least 30 days before the proposed or scheduled date of any sale”

Utah Code § 38-2-4 (effective 5/7/2025)
Sell or title it

“no property may be sold earlier than 45 days after completion of the repair work”

Utah Code § 38-2-4 (effective 5/7/2025)
Get it back

“(4) A lienee may have the lienee's property released from any lien claimed on it under this chapter by filing with the clerk of a court a cash or surety bond, payable to the person claiming the lien, and conditioned for the payment of any judgment that may be recovered on the lien, with costs, interest, and storage fees.”

Utah Code § 38-2-4 (effective 5/7/2025)
Get it back

“(5)(a) The lienor has 60 days after receiving notice that the lienee has filed the bond provided in Subsection (4) to file suit to foreclose the lien.”

Utah Code § 38-2-4 (effective 5/7/2025)
Sell or title it

“Nothing in this chapter shall take away the right of action of the party to whom such lien is given for that party's charges, or for any residue thereof, after such sale of the property.”

Utah Code § 38-2-5 (effective 5/1/2024)

Compare body shop lien laws in all 32 states

Can the insurer make you use aftermarket parts, and what must it disclose?

What it means in Utah

Unless the insurer gives the insured written notice, it can't specify non-OEM aftermarket crash parts (replacement exterior sheet metal or plastic parts) in the repair of the insured's car. When an insurer authorizes or specifies one, the written estimate must clearly identify each such part and carry, in at least 10-point font on or attached to the insured's copy, a set disclosure that the estimate is based on the insurer's authorization, that such parts must be at least equivalent in kind and quality in fit, quality and performance, and that their warranties come from the parts maker or distributor rather than the car maker. The Insurance Department and the commissioner are not required to administer or enforce that estimate requirement. For a policy issued on or after October 1, 2026, the insurer must also give the insured a written notice at issuance and renewal that it may authorize or specify aftermarket crash parts; that notice is informational only and does not change the coverage. A non-OEM aftermarket crash part must carry its maker's logo or name, visible after installation whenever practicable. On a consumer repair, your itemized invoice must list each part, whether it is new, used, rebuilt or after market, and its cost, and before the work you must give written notice that the customer may inspect a replaced or repaired part.

An aftermarket crash part is only a replacement for the nonmechanical sheet metal or plastic parts that generally make up the exterior of a car, including inner and outer panels, and it can be OEM or non-OEM (Utah Code 31A-22-317). The section speaks of an insured; whether it reaches a third-party claimant's repair, whether an estimate your shop writes on the insurer's authorization must carry the disclosure, and who enforces subsection (3) are questions for a lawyer. Nothing in the section requires an insurer to cover OEM aftermarket crash parts unless the policy expressly provides it, and no statute or rule in our Utah collection requires an insurer to pay for OEM parts. The shop duties come from Rule R152-11-305 under the Utah Consumer Sales Practices Act, where failing to meet them is a deceptive act, and reach only a consumer transaction (primarily personal, family or household purposes); whether a fleet or business customer's repair is one is a question for a lawyer. The rule lists exceptions to letting the customer inspect a replaced part, among them a written waiver given after the work is done and the total cost is presented.

The law's own words

Insurer

“(1) Unless an insurer gives an insured notice in writing an insurer may not specify the use of non-OEM aftermarket crash parts in the repair of an insured's motor vehicle.”

Utah Code § 31A-22-319 (effective 5/6/2026)
Insurer

From a list that begins: “(3) When an insurer authorizes or specifies the use of a non-OEM aftermarket crash part, the written estimate shall:”

“(a) clearly identify each non-OEM aftermarket crash part; and”

Utah Code § 31A-22-319 (effective 5/6/2026)
Insurer

From a list that begins: “(3) When an insurer authorizes or specifies the use of a non-OEM aftermarket crash part, the written estimate shall:”

“(b) contain the following disclosure in at least 10-point font, that appears on or is attached to the insured's copy of the estimate: "This estimate has been prepared based on the authorization of your insurer and the use of aftermarket crash parts not made by the original manufacturer of your motor vehicle. Parts used in the repair of your vehicle that are made by a manufacturer other than the original manufacturer are required to be at least equivalent in kind and quality in terms of fit, quality, and performance. Warranties applicable to these replacement parts are provided by the manufacturer or distributor of these parts rather than the manufacturer of your vehicle."”

Utah Code § 31A-22-319 (effective 5/6/2026)
Parts standard

“(1) Any aftermarket crash part supplied by a nonoriginal equipment manufacturer for use in a motor vehicle in this state shall have the logo or name of the nonoriginal equipment manufacturer affixed or inscribed on the aftermarket crash part.”

Utah Code § 31A-22-318 (Renumbered and Amended by Chapter 8, 1995 General Session)
Insurer

“(5) Notwithstanding Sections 31A-2-101 and 31A-2-201, the department and the commissioner are not required to administer or otherwise enforce Subsection (3).”

Utah Code § 31A-22-319 (effective 5/6/2026)
Shop

From a list that begins: “(ii) provide the consumer an itemized list of any repair, inspection, or other similar service performed and the reason for the repair, inspection, or other similar service, including:”

“(A) a list of any part, whether the part is new, used, rebuilt, or after market, and each part's cost;”

Utah Admin. Code R152-11-305 (effective 9/22/2026)
Shop

“(iii) provide to the consumer written notice before performing the repair, inspection, or other similar service that a replaced or repaired part may be inspected by the consumer”

Utah Admin. Code R152-11-305 (effective 9/22/2026)

Compare aftermarket parts laws in all 32 states

Can your customer invoke appraisal when the insurer's number is too low?

What it means in Utah

A third-party total loss settlement must be based on the market value or actual cost of a comparable car at the time of loss, including all applicable taxes, license fees and transfer of ownership fees. Settling a claim for less than the amount the insurer would be charged if repairs were made is an unfair practice unless the claimant agrees or the policy provides for it, and so is offering a first party claimant substantially less than the claim's reasonable value as established by an independent source. On notice that a first party claimant can't buy a comparable vehicle at market value within 30 days of receiving a cash total loss settlement, the insurer must reopen its file; one of the options the rule lists for the insurer is concluding the settlement under the policy's appraisal section. The time limit for suing on the policy is tolled while the parties conduct an appraisal or arbitration procedure. No statute or rule in our Utah collection requires an appraisal clause or says who may demand appraisal.

Whether a policy's appraisal clause applies, and who may invoke it, turns on the policy's wording and is a question for the Utah Insurance Department or a lawyer. The insurer need not reopen the file if its settlement documents gave written notice of a specified comparable vehicle that could be bought for the market value it set. A first party suit on the policy must be started within three years after the inception of the loss, except as Subsections 31A-22-305(11) and 31A-22-307(7) provide, which our collection does not include (Utah Code 31A-21-313). Rule R590-190 is enforced by the Utah Insurance Department and says nothing about a private right to sue, and Utah Code 31A-26-303(5) says that section creates no private cause of action.

The law's own words

Other dispute rules

“(2)(a) A total loss settlement with a third party claimant shall be based on the market value or actual cost of a comparable automobile at the time of loss including all applicable taxes, license fees, and transfer of ownership fees.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)
Other dispute rules

From a list that begins: “The commissioner finds the following acts to be misleading, deceptive, unfairly discriminatory, overreaching, or an unreasonable restraint on competition in settling a claim:”

“(1) settling a claim for an amount that is less than the amount the insurer would be charged if repairs were made, unless the amount is agreed to by the claimant or provided for by the policy;”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-12 (effective 6/7/2024)
Other dispute rules

From a list that begins: “The commissioner finds that the following acts or general business practices are unfair claim settlement practices and are misleading, deceptive, unfairly discriminatory, overreaching, or an unreasonable restraint on competition in settling a claim:”

“(6) offering a first party claimant substantially less than a claim's reasonable value as established by an independent source;”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-9 (effective 6/7/2024)
Other dispute rules

From a list that begins: “(ii) An insurer shall reopen its claim file and comply with the following procedures upon notice that a first party claimant cannot purchase a comparable vehicle at market value within 30 days of receiving a cash settlement payment under this Subsection (1)(b); and”

“(D) conclude the loss settlement under the appraisal section of the policy in force at the time of the loss.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)
Other dispute rules

“(5) The period of limitation is tolled during the period in which the parties conduct an appraisal or arbitration procedure prescribed by the insurance policy, by law, or as agreed to by the parties.”

Utah Code § 31A-21-313 (effective 5/3/2023)

Compare auto appraisal clause laws in all 32 states

How does the insurer set the labor rate, and do labor rate surveys have rules?

What it means in Utah

If the insurer prepares or approves a repair estimate, the estimated cost must reasonably be expected to repair the damage. Settling a claim for less than the amount the insurer would be charged if repairs were made is an unfair practice unless the claimant agrees or the policy provides for it, and so is refusing to pay a claim without a reasonable investigation. If the insurer elects to repair the car and designates a specific shop, it must have the car restored to its condition before the loss at no added cost to the claimant beyond what the policy states. The only rule in our Utah collection that limits what an insurer must pay for repair work is for windshield-related driver assistance work: an insurer that pays for glass repair, replacement or recalibration on a car whose driver assistance feature is tied to the windshield may not be required to pay more than a fair and competitive price for the local market area. Our Utah collection has no labor rate rule, labor rate survey rule or prevailing rate standard for body work; the words labor rate appear nowhere in it.

What the amount the insurer would be charged if repairs were made means against a shop's own rates is a question for a lawyer, as is whether a repair shop is ever a claimant under Rule R590-190. In Rule R590-190 a claimant is a first party claimant, a third party claimant, or both. Utah Code 41-6a-1645 reaches only glass repair, replacement or recalibration on a car with a driver assistance feature tied to the windshield; it is not a rate rule for collision repair. Rule R590-190 is enforced by the Utah Insurance Department and says nothing about a private right to sue, and Utah Code 31A-26-303(5) says that section creates no private cause of action.

The law's own words

What the insurer pays

“(6)(a) If an insurer prepares or approves an estimate for automobile repairs, the estimated cost shall reasonably be expected to repair the damage to the automobile.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)
What the insurer pays

From a list that begins: “The commissioner finds the following acts to be misleading, deceptive, unfairly discriminatory, overreaching, or an unreasonable restraint on competition in settling a claim:”

“(1) settling a claim for an amount that is less than the amount the insurer would be charged if repairs were made, unless the amount is agreed to by the claimant or provided for by the policy;”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-12 (effective 6/7/2024)
Related claim rule

From a list that begins: “The commissioner finds that the following acts or general business practices are unfair claim settlement practices and are misleading, deceptive, unfairly discriminatory, overreaching, or an unreasonable restraint on competition in settling a claim:”

“(5) refusing to pay a claim without conducting a reasonable investigation;”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-9 (effective 6/7/2024)
What the insurer pays

“(8) If an insurer elects to repair an automobile and designates a specific repair shop for the repairs, the insurer shall cause the damaged automobile to be restored to its condition before the loss at no additional cost to the claimant other than as stated in the policy and within a reasonable period.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)
Survey or rate standard

“(b) An insurance company that pays for work described in Subsection (3)(a) may not be required to pay more than a fair and competitive price for the local market area.”

Utah Code § 41-6a-1645 (effective 5/5/2021)

Compare labor rate survey laws in all 32 states

Can the insurer cap paint and materials?

What it means in Utah

If the insurer prepares or approves a repair estimate, the estimated cost must reasonably be expected to repair the damage. Settling a claim for less than the amount the insurer would be charged if repairs were made is an unfair practice unless the claimant agrees or the policy provides for it. When done often enough to indicate a general business practice, failing to promptly give the insured a reasonable explanation of the basis for a denial or a compromise offer, and not attempting in good faith to reach a prompt, fair and equitable settlement once liability is reasonably clear, are unfair claim settlement practices. No insurance statute or rule in our Utah collection addresses paint and materials or capping them, and the insurance rules never mention paint; the only rules in it that mention paint sold to a body shop are sales tax rules.

Whether a low materials allowance breaks these rules, and what the amount the insurer would be charged means against a shop's own charges, are questions for the Utah Insurance Department or a lawyer. In Rule R590-190 a claimant is a first party claimant, a third party claimant, or both. Rule R590-190 is enforced by the Utah Insurance Department and says nothing about a private right to sue, and Utah Code 31A-26-303(5) says that section creates no private cause of action.

The law's own words

What the insurer pays

“(6)(a) If an insurer prepares or approves an estimate for automobile repairs, the estimated cost shall reasonably be expected to repair the damage to the automobile.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-11 (effective 6/7/2024)
What the insurer pays

From a list that begins: “The commissioner finds the following acts to be misleading, deceptive, unfairly discriminatory, overreaching, or an unreasonable restraint on competition in settling a claim:”

“(1) settling a claim for an amount that is less than the amount the insurer would be charged if repairs were made, unless the amount is agreed to by the claimant or provided for by the policy;”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-12 (effective 6/7/2024)
Related claim rule

From a list that begins: “(3) Each of the following is an unfair claim settlement practice if committed or performed with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice by an insurer or persons representing an insurer:”

“(e) failing to promptly provide to the insured a reasonable explanation of the basis for denial of a claim or for the offer of a compromise settlement;”

Utah Code § 31A-26-303 (Amended by Chapter 91, 1987 General Session)
Related claim rule

From a list that begins: “(3) Each of the following is an unfair claim settlement practice if committed or performed with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice by an insurer or persons representing an insurer:”

“(h) not attempting in good faith to effectuate a prompt, fair, and equitable settlement of claims in which liability is reasonably clear.”

Utah Code § 31A-26-303 (Amended by Chapter 91, 1987 General Session)

Compare paint and materials cap laws in all 32 states

How long does the insurer have to respond, decide and pay a claim?

What it means in Utah

The insurer must acknowledge a notice of loss within 15 days unless it pays within that time or reasonably explains the failure, and must give a claimant a substantive response within 15 days when one is requested. Within 30 days after a complete proof of loss, it must finish its investigation and tell a first party claimant whether the claim is accepted or denied, unless the investigation can't reasonably be finished in that time; then it must say within those 30 days why it needs more time and, while the investigation stays open, send a letter every 45 days unless the claimant has a lawyer or public adjuster. Failing to deliver or mail the amount owed on a first party or third party claim within 30 days after the insurer receives written proof of a covered loss and its amount is an unfair practice; a partial amount supported by written proof or investigation is due within 30 days when proof of the entire loss is missing, and a payment is not overdue if the insurer has reasonable evidence to dispute its responsibility. Failing to pay interest at the legal rate on overdue first and third party amounts is also an unfair practice, and Utah Code 15-1-1 sets the legal rate for a contract that names no rate at 10% per annum. A day is a calendar day.

The rule points to Title 15 for the legal rate; whether that 10% rate applies to a given overdue claim, who may collect the interest, and how Utah Code 15-1-1, which speaks of contracts, applies to a third-party claimant or a shop, are questions for a lawyer. Utah Code 31A-26-301 requires an insurer to timely pay every valid claim made by an insured, but states no number of days and applies only to claims for first party benefits. The Insurance Department may order forfeitures for violating an insurance statute or rule (Utah Code 31A-2-308). Rule R590-190 is enforced by the Utah Insurance Department and says nothing about a private right to sue, and Utah Code 31A-26-303(5) says that section creates no private cause of action. A first party suit on the policy must be started within three years after the inception of the loss, except as Subsections 31A-22-305(11) and 31A-22-307(7) provide, which our collection does not include, and a policy may not shorten that time (Utah Code 31A-21-313 and 31A-21-314). Unless prejudice beyond the delay is alleged by verified complaint, a suit to compel payment under the policy can't be brought until the earliest of 60 days after proof of loss is furnished as the policy requires, the insurer's waiver of proof of loss, or its denial of full payment (31A-21-313(4)).

The law's own words

Respond

“(1) An insurer shall acknowledge receiving a notice of loss within 15 days of receipt unless:”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-6 (effective 6/7/2024)
Respond

“(3) Within 15 days, an insurer shall provide a substantive response to a claimant if a response has been requested.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-6 (effective 6/7/2024)
Accept or deny

“(2)(a) Within 30 days after receiving a complete proof of loss, an insurer shall complete its investigation of the claim and shall notify the first party claimant of its acceptance or denial of the claim unless the investigation cannot reasonably be completed within that time.”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-10 (effective 6/7/2024)
Pay

From a list that begins: “The commissioner finds that the following acts or general business practices are unfair claim settlement practices and are misleading, deceptive, unfairly discriminatory, overreaching, or an unreasonable restraint on competition in settling a claim:”

“(21) failing to deliver or mail the amount owed on a first party or third party claim within 30 days after the insurer receives written proof of a covered loss and its amount, except:”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-9 (effective 6/7/2024)
If late

From a list that begins: “The commissioner finds that the following acts or general business practices are unfair claim settlement practices and are misleading, deceptive, unfairly discriminatory, overreaching, or an unreasonable restraint on competition in settling a claim:”

“(20) except for a failure to pay personal injury protection expenses when due, failing to pay interest at the legal rate, as provided in Title 15, Contracts and Obligations in General, on first party and third party claim amounts that are overdue under this rule; and”

Utah Admin. Code R590-190-9 (effective 6/7/2024)
If late

“(2) Unless the parties to a lawful written, verbal, or implied contract expressly specify a different rate of interest, the legal rate of interest for the contract, including a contract for services, a loan or forbearance of any money, goods, or services, or a claim for breach of contract is 10% per annum.”

Utah Code § 15-1-1 (effective 5/14/2019)

Compare claim payment deadlines in all 32 states

Other states

All state law guides

Utah collision repair associations

Trade associations speak for Utah shops before the legislature and the insurance regulator. See Utah collision repair associations in our industry associations directory.

Where these quotes come from

Each quote is copied from the official text published by Utah's legislature or agencies, which Collision CoPilot captures and monitors for changes. Where a row quotes agency guidance, session-law text, a court decision or a copy hosted by another publisher, the citation says so. Each citation links to its source and shows the edition or effective date of the text.

Utah Code text is published by the Utah State Legislature, Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel, at le.utah.gov, and Utah Administrative Code text by the Utah Office of Administrative Rules at adminrules.utah.gov. Each Utah citation links to that publisher's page for the section or rule.

What this page is not

This page quotes the law. It does not tell you how it applies to a particular claim or vehicle, and it is not legal advice. BainbridgeAI LLC is not a law firm. Rules turn on policy language, deadlines and facts the law does not settle. For a dispute on a real file, talk to Utah's insurance regulator or a licensed attorney in Utah.

If your state is not listed

Collision CoPilot covers 32 states today and adds more as shops ask for them. When you sign up, choose “My state isn’t listed” and tell us which one; every request moves that state up the build list.

Working a Utah claim?

Collision CoPilot puts Utah's full insurance and repair law, more than 22,000 DEG inquiries and collision playbooks inside ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, so your team can find the exact rule, check the source and draft a reply for you to review.

See Collision CoPilot